Fears of repo market price dislocation largely contained over year end, says ERCC report
27 January 2023 EU
Image: zatevakhin/stock.adobe.com
The ICMA European Repo and Collateral Committee has released its annual summary of repo market performance around the year end.
Traditionally published by the ERCC in January, the report reflects on how end-of-year conditions have impacted EUR, GBP, USD and JPY repo markets, drawing on market data and accounts supplied by buy-side and sell-side market participants.
Written by International Capital Markets Association (ICMA) senior director and deputy head of market practice and regulatory policy Andy Hill, the latest version of this report indicates that participants in euro repo markets had started preparing early for the 2022 year-end and with some degree of nervousness, with the turn becoming a focus of attention as early as August.
This accords with SFT’s own research in the market, which indicates that some market participants had begun preparations for the turn as early as July or August (see, for example, SFT Issue 319, pp 18-35).
Hill finds that by late September and early October, term trades over year-end were implying turn rates of 1000bps below €STR for German collateral, with the FX basis indicating a notional euro rate of -14 per cent.
Pricing improved in the run-up to the year-end, such that by 28 December, German collateral (GC and some specific repo) averaged €STR-350bps, French collateral averaged €STR-290bps and Italian collateral averaged €STR-195bps.
The report indicates that Spanish collateral, which had become more difficult to source into December, averaged around €STR-300bps over the turn.
Several factors are likely to have been important in containing price disruption over the 2022-23 turn. In general terms, financial authorities began to take steps to address concerns around collateral scarcity and to reduce excess liquidity in the banking system. In late October, the German Finance Ministry, Deutsche Finanzgenturn, announced that it would make €54 billion in German bonds across 18 German ISINs available through repo channels - an action that SFT has addressed in some detail in other articles (see SFT, 315, pp 14-7 or SFT 319, pp 18-35, op.cit).
Also, the European Central Bank raised its borrowing facility against cash on the Public Sector Purchases Programme (PSPP) and Pandemic Emergency Purchase Programme (PEPP) from €150 billion to €250 billion, and it created windows for early repayment of Targeted Long-term Refinancing Operations (TLTRO) funding in late November and December.
The ERCC report finds that, as often happens, trading volumes declined significantly going into year-end, although the tail-off in activity seems to have come earlier than previous years, with a notable drop going into the final week of the year. This can be seen in RFR volumes as well as in Eurex outstanding balances. “This probably also reflects the degree of nervousness and early attention going into the year-end, with market participants squaring their books well in advance of the turn,” says the report (p 13).
On balance, Hill indicates that some widening in repo market pricing was certainly significant, particularly when measured against pricing levels in some other markets. “It is also important to remember these pricing levels relate to the interbank, primarily centrally cleared, market,” he says. “Pricing for end investors in many cases will have been even more extreme” (p 3).
For GBP repo markets, volatility was “relatively benign” over the turn and collateral availability appeared to improve, despite preceding concerns that sterling repo rates could move lower owing to significant amounts of cash being invested at the short end of the yield curve.
The report identifies a number of factors that were potentially important in offsetting any reserve-collateral disequilibrium, including stronger term reverse repo activity, quantitative tightening, net positive issuance and a positive FX basis.
For US repo markets, the ERCC concludes that record uptake of more than US$2.5 trillion in the Federal Reserve overnight reserve repo (RRP) was important in ensuring a “smooth and uneventful year end”.
For JPY repo, the report finds that term repo rates tightened over the year end, particularly for special repo, but the overnight rate remained relatively stable. Although the change in the Bank of Japan’s monetary policy appeared to catch the market off guard to some extent, this did not result in significant price dislocation in JPY repo markets.
The ICMA ERCC briefing note on the European repo market at year end has been published each January since 2017. It draws heavily on data supplied by Eurex, Bloomberg and CME Group Benchmark Administration.
Commentary and insights from AXA IM, Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Barclays, BlackRock, Eurex, HVB Unicredit, J.P. Morgan, LCH and UBS were key in preparing the report.
Traditionally published by the ERCC in January, the report reflects on how end-of-year conditions have impacted EUR, GBP, USD and JPY repo markets, drawing on market data and accounts supplied by buy-side and sell-side market participants.
Written by International Capital Markets Association (ICMA) senior director and deputy head of market practice and regulatory policy Andy Hill, the latest version of this report indicates that participants in euro repo markets had started preparing early for the 2022 year-end and with some degree of nervousness, with the turn becoming a focus of attention as early as August.
This accords with SFT’s own research in the market, which indicates that some market participants had begun preparations for the turn as early as July or August (see, for example, SFT Issue 319, pp 18-35).
Hill finds that by late September and early October, term trades over year-end were implying turn rates of 1000bps below €STR for German collateral, with the FX basis indicating a notional euro rate of -14 per cent.
Pricing improved in the run-up to the year-end, such that by 28 December, German collateral (GC and some specific repo) averaged €STR-350bps, French collateral averaged €STR-290bps and Italian collateral averaged €STR-195bps.
The report indicates that Spanish collateral, which had become more difficult to source into December, averaged around €STR-300bps over the turn.
Several factors are likely to have been important in containing price disruption over the 2022-23 turn. In general terms, financial authorities began to take steps to address concerns around collateral scarcity and to reduce excess liquidity in the banking system. In late October, the German Finance Ministry, Deutsche Finanzgenturn, announced that it would make €54 billion in German bonds across 18 German ISINs available through repo channels - an action that SFT has addressed in some detail in other articles (see SFT, 315, pp 14-7 or SFT 319, pp 18-35, op.cit).
Also, the European Central Bank raised its borrowing facility against cash on the Public Sector Purchases Programme (PSPP) and Pandemic Emergency Purchase Programme (PEPP) from €150 billion to €250 billion, and it created windows for early repayment of Targeted Long-term Refinancing Operations (TLTRO) funding in late November and December.
The ERCC report finds that, as often happens, trading volumes declined significantly going into year-end, although the tail-off in activity seems to have come earlier than previous years, with a notable drop going into the final week of the year. This can be seen in RFR volumes as well as in Eurex outstanding balances. “This probably also reflects the degree of nervousness and early attention going into the year-end, with market participants squaring their books well in advance of the turn,” says the report (p 13).
On balance, Hill indicates that some widening in repo market pricing was certainly significant, particularly when measured against pricing levels in some other markets. “It is also important to remember these pricing levels relate to the interbank, primarily centrally cleared, market,” he says. “Pricing for end investors in many cases will have been even more extreme” (p 3).
For GBP repo markets, volatility was “relatively benign” over the turn and collateral availability appeared to improve, despite preceding concerns that sterling repo rates could move lower owing to significant amounts of cash being invested at the short end of the yield curve.
The report identifies a number of factors that were potentially important in offsetting any reserve-collateral disequilibrium, including stronger term reverse repo activity, quantitative tightening, net positive issuance and a positive FX basis.
For US repo markets, the ERCC concludes that record uptake of more than US$2.5 trillion in the Federal Reserve overnight reserve repo (RRP) was important in ensuring a “smooth and uneventful year end”.
For JPY repo, the report finds that term repo rates tightened over the year end, particularly for special repo, but the overnight rate remained relatively stable. Although the change in the Bank of Japan’s monetary policy appeared to catch the market off guard to some extent, this did not result in significant price dislocation in JPY repo markets.
The ICMA ERCC briefing note on the European repo market at year end has been published each January since 2017. It draws heavily on data supplied by Eurex, Bloomberg and CME Group Benchmark Administration.
Commentary and insights from AXA IM, Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Barclays, BlackRock, Eurex, HVB Unicredit, J.P. Morgan, LCH and UBS were key in preparing the report.
← Previous industry article
IMN: Investment in data architecture key to drive trading and operational performance
IMN: Investment in data architecture key to drive trading and operational performance
NO FEE, NO RISK
100% ON RETURNS If you invest in only one securities finance news source this year, make sure it is your free subscription to Securities Finance Times
100% ON RETURNS If you invest in only one securities finance news source this year, make sure it is your free subscription to Securities Finance Times
